What’s the distinction in high quality between a $500 35mm Rokinon lens and a $26,000 Arri Grasp Prime? That’s precisely what Filmmaker and YouTuber Ryon Connolly of Movie Riot wished to seek out out.
Actual World Take a look at
Whereas the controversy about utilizing reasonably priced versus “skilled” has been a long-standing one, Connolly determined to place his cash (actually) the place his mouth was to see precisely what the variations had been between the 2 lenses when put in real-world working situations. Whereas a number of the outcomes had been fairly apparent, there have been fairly a couple of surprises sprinkled all through the ten-minute video comparability.
Mounting each lenses on the identical mannequin of Blackmagic URSA Mini Professional cameras and matching the focal lengths as carefully as attainable (32mm ARRI vs 35mm on the Rokinon), the workforce shot quite a lot of clips in a number of situations together with in-studio, in opposition to inexperienced screens, and open air aimed into the solar.
Considerably surprisingly, the Rokinon truly did carry out properly in lots of the setups with essentially the most obvious and noticeable distinction being the bokeh patterns (considerably worse on the Rokinon in comparison with the Arri) and the colour rendition. The Arri lens captured extra “true to life” colours whereas the Rokinon typically added a splash of heat to the body.
Most Received’t See a Distinction
All through Connolly’s testing, he discovered that the Rokinon did rather a lot higher than anticipated particularly contemplating the huge distinction in value. Not everybody goes to note the bokeh variations, and the colour points may very well be simply matched and compensated for in post-production. When creating content material for smaller screens like YouTube, the variations (with some changes) had been nearly unnoticeable.
Nonetheless, there are causes he would choose the Grasp Prime if given the chance.
“I don’t like that I don’t have the selection, which implies the management is taken out of my arms,” he says. “With the Grasp Primes, I can put filters on the lens and I can add issues in submit, however with the Rokinon I’m compelled right into a subtractive course of as a substitute of an additive one which isn’t factor.”
Connolly mentions that when posting content material on YouTube and different social media retailers, the footage might be compressed considerably, making the variations even tougher to identify. However when capturing for the “large display screen” the Grasp Primes are clearly the higher selection and the efficiency distinction is considerably extra noticeable.
To see extra of Connolly’s work you should definitely go to the Movie Riot YouTube Channel.